Is Bree's Dad Still Alive?

tayduh1987 · Post by **tayduh1987** » Fri Feb 02, 2007 11:55 am

nobackspacebutton wrote:Its interesting, Josh, to say that you would think she would notice her Dad if he was there--but if she is not being aware of her surroundings---she would not be paying attention to every little detail around them. It seems like in these shots, this man is out of Bree's sight. Although she is looking for Daniel, her attention would be focused on the bowling alley more so than the parking lot.

Since the order took her 'dads' body, there was no way to actually prove that he was shot to death. Its still a possibility he could be alive. Either that, or the Creators are using the same person for an additional character.

I think that Bree isn't looking for her dad so she isn't going to be looking for similarities in some guy that is in a parking lot. She believes he is dead so she isn't going to look for him.

licoricesniper · Post by **licoricesniper** » Fri Feb 02, 2007 12:31 pm

I really don't think it's her dad. I think the similarities between the guy and her dad are because they are just using the same person for both roles.

Of course, it isn't entirely impossible that her dad is still alive...I suppose we will eventually find out one way or another.

tayduh1987 · Post by **tayduh1987** » Fri Feb 02, 2007 1:00 pm

I hope that on Sunday we find out that her Dad SURVIVED and he's the one that took Daniel away to tell him more!

autumneternal · Post by **autumneternal** » Fri Feb 02, 2007 2:32 pm

Here's a crazy thought! Remember back in the "The Unthinkable Happened..." video, when Jonas reacted to seeing Bree's dad by saying "are you sure that's her dad?" What if the reason he reacted like that was because he recognized her father as 'The Cowboy' that they're currently chasing?

It's just crazy enough to be true!

tayduh1987 · Post by **tayduh1987** » Fri Feb 02, 2007 3:00 pm

autumneternal wrote:Here's a crazy thought! Remember back in the "The Unthinkable Happened..." video, when Jonas reacted to seeing Bree's dad by saying "are you sure that's her dad?" What if the reason he reacted like that was because he recognized her father as 'The Cowboy' that they're currently chasing?

It's just crazy enough to be true!

Wow...that is a crazy thought. You're correct when you say that it is crazy enough to be true!!!!!!!

platypusrex256 · Post by **platypusrex256** » Wed Feb 07, 2007 3:01 pm

why isnt this a poll? i love polls. ;-p

anyhow... yes. bree's dad is still alive. i still believe that everything is just an insane illusion or game. actual death doesn't fit in the perameters of the game. so yeah.

as things are going, bree might be winning.

HoorayForMeImMakingOut · Wed Feb 07, 2007 3:13 pm

I think that he is really dead, there isn't a point in the story for him anymore, or at least thats my opinion.

tayduh1987 · Post by **tayduh1987** » Wed Feb 07, 2007 3:32 pm

i think he's going to reappear and save the day!!!!