Lonelygirl15

21 I Probably Shouldn't Post This...
...
Bree: It's something that I believe in and why is it such a big deal to you?
Daniel: Whatever.
Bree: It's my religion...
Daniel: Ok...
Bree: ...it's my beliefs, there’s a million fucking different religions in the world.

28 A Change In My Life

...I've been chosen to participate in a ceremony. The ceremony is a really big deal in my religion. ....

40 My Difficult Decision.
....
And he flipped out. He said that my religion was getting in the way of our whatever it is, and he told me that I had to choose between him or my religion.

Erm, OK. So based on Bree calling it a religion and Gemma saying 'it's more like a secret society, it's not a religion at all' what are we supposed to believe?

I have my theories, but what do you people think?

PushedButton wrote:21 I Probably Shouldn't Post This...
...
Bree: It's something that I believe in and why is it such a big deal to you?
Daniel: Whatever.
Bree: It's my religion...
Daniel: Ok...
Bree: ...it's my beliefs, there’s a million fucking different religions in the world.

28 A Change In My Life

...I've been chosen to participate in a ceremony. The ceremony is a really big deal in my religion. ....

40 My Difficult Decision.
....
And he flipped out. He said that my religion was getting in the way of our whatever it is, and he told me that I had to choose between him or my religion.

Erm, OK. So based on Bree calling it a religion and Gemma saying 'it's more like a secret society, it's not a religion at all' what are we supposed to believe?

I have my theories, but what do you people think?

Perhaps Bree was told it was a religion; in other words lied to.

Not to be nasty or anything, but a lot of people keeping looking for contradictions where there are none. It's kinda funny.

I've always felt that Gemma has never really had Bree's best interests at heart. I'm not certain we can trust anything she has to say.

twjaniak wrote:I've always felt that Gemma has never really had Bree's best interests at heart. I'm not certain we can trust anything she has to say.

Good to know your opinion on this...makes me feel less insane. (not much less, but less)

I know!
It fits that it's not a religion, but as you said
how many times has Bree said it's my religion

twjaniak wrote:I've always felt that Gemma has never really had Bree's best interests at heart. I'm not certain we can trust anything she has to say.

Oo. If you don't trust her, TW, then I'm going to have to start looking at her vids more critically.

Unless maybe we shouldn't trust you . . . ?

Damn. Now I'm getting paranoid about everybody.

Languorous Lass wrote:

twjaniak wrote:I've always felt that Gemma has never really had Bree's best interests at heart. I'm not certain we can trust anything she has to say.

Oo. If you don't trust her, TW, then I'm going to have to start looking at her vids more critically.

Unless maybe we shouldn't trust you . . . ?

Damn. Now I'm getting paranoid about everybody.

I'm glad you said this, lass. I've been thinking for a while now that the mods know more than they are telling us (could they be the creators themselves?) and that they could be throwing people of the trail when they get close to a discovery.

Maybe not throwing off the tail, per se... but they do seem pretty omnipotent at times, don't they?

My two cents: Bree grows up in a yes, religious commune, worshiping something, maybe like Thelema, and all she knows are the "eldars" (now she says deacons) and her parent's religion that she takes very seriously and yet her parents aren't part of the 'Order of Denderah" and "won't even be allowed to come." Of course the deacons are more powerful than she realizes, and when they choose her (why?) for the ceremony they've got something bad in mind that even her parents are taken surprise by, that the deacons really are a secret society. That's if we trust Gemma. If we don't, completely different story.

twjaniak wrote:I've always felt that Gemma has never really had Bree's best interests at heart. I'm not certain we can trust anything she has to say.

my thoughts exactly.

I think she's lying to us.