Lonelygirl15

I liked her.
Mainly I just thought she was really pretty.
As for if she should come back..
I am on the fence honestly.
Parts of me wants her back, but then again, the other part says no.
I don't really know why, but that is how I feel.
ahahaha

The only way I would accept Gemma as being back would be to seal up all the many huge loose ends! Well if they wrote her in its not for me to accept, but still, LG staff has been making WAY too many leaps and bounds in logic, that is why they were originally found out and had to tell everyone it was a set-up, well now we all know, but no one likes the craziness of an un set storyline... i just dont see it happening, or hope it doesnt, i dont see a good way to explain it away..

also as seeing that tachy op and brother wont be mentioned in TAAG videos, there will be no way to seal up loose ends, and no nikki cant do it, no matter how much i like her!

I have to agree with Hippie. The Gemma story is closed.

cosmicdancer wrote:I don't think we really got to see her play villain. We saw her act friendly towards them (even if it was completely false) and we saw her hanging with Lucy and talking about Op but besides that we didn't get to really *see* her play 'bad guy'.

That's what made her even better to me - how tricky and two faced she was. She did say on the phone that she was considering the D in Op Aphid though:).

I guess the Op Aphid storyline is gone and I feel a little lost. I wouldn't mind Gemma coming back with the whole "brother never could kill me, he let me get away, but never told his sister that I survived, and then i hid out...until I was able to plan a way to get him back and kill him and his sister" or something along those lines, you know? it would fill whatever void there is. And the whole fact that this scenario is entirely implausible and doesn't flow - that's totally correct - it doesn't. But we just lost tachy brother and opaphid and that doesn't flow either so things are going to be shaky for a bit.

I guess I want some of the old storyline back because I'm a little sad with the way things are going right now.

well didnt bree make up the fake cermony to fool daniel because lucy/the order people told her... couldnt gemma actually not be all that bad and have been made to tell bree those things??? just a thought!(i've seen the tachyon videos and they dont make her out to be evil... just that she didnt particularly like bree!! and her little purple monkey too. mwuhahahahahaha oops sorry got gemma mixed up with the wiked witch in wizard of oz! she was just misunderstood )

The Creators have a hard enough time keeping up now. They'll be having migraines if they bring Gemma back.

Actually I don't think it would be that hard to bring Gemma back in. Take this following hypothetical (and admittedly somewhat corny) list of videos:

Video 1 - The Beast Unleashed!
Someone came in the bunker last night and stole Daniel's alcohol. Not surprisingly, Daniel is really ticked off. He's been yelling and screaming at both Jonas and me. The funny thing is the thief only wanted the alcohol... what's up with that? -Bree

Video 2 - Finding the Thief
For the sake of everyone's sanity, the three of us are going to find the thief that stole Daniel's booze. What he doesn't know though, is that Bree and I have made sure Daniel doesn't get a drop of it back -Jonas

Video 3 - Would You Believe...?
OK, we finally found the thief. The shocker here is that it's Gemma! Bree and Jonas don't know what to think, I'm just pissed that she drank what I had left. They're debating whether to bring her back to the bunker with us, while I just try to figure out what I'm going to do with out anything to drink... Maybe I'll take Jonas up on his offer -Daniel

Video 4- Interrogation Redux
Alright, Gemma, tell us what you know. And do it before I tie you to a chair just like I did Jonas! -Bree

Video 5- She Doesn't Remember Anything
Hmmm... Gemma doesn't seem to remember anything about what she did before she was hit by "Brother". Maybe OpAphid or the Order wiped her mind after she was shot, and that's why she thinks she's a homeless alcoholic who has no idea what the Order is... -Bree

Video 6- I Wish I Could Remember...
I honestly can't remember anything. I wish the videos that I had supposedly done up made any kind of sense... I feel like I've lost the last year of my life... -Gemma

See, not hard!

i want her back. i truely adore her smile.

JACKIE PLZ COME BACK at least come back from school at least for summer vacation.

besides i think she should just randomly to let us know she's alive somehow in the LGuniverse. but she doesnt have to play a big part of the story line. she just has to be seen alive without explanation.

i wonder if the creators considederd the fact that it's not neccissary to have an explanation or have any key of figuring it out.

it's just unexplained. we can handel that.

blade8r wrote:i wonder if the creators considederd the fact that it's not neccissary to have an explanation or have any key of figuring it out.

it's just unexplained. we can handel that.

Wait, what?

i actually didn't like gemma... i always thought she kinda like dragged the plot. like the second she left, everything seemed to pick up. just my opinion

She was never confirmed dead. Not by anyone. People assumed the meaning of OpAphid words meant that she'd physically passed, but that doesn't mean anything. Gemma's as dead as Jonas' parents.

That being said, Gemma's presence never made sense in the storyline, anyway. Bringing her back would make a lot of people go

gemma also seemed like a glenn creation so that could be another reason for her not coming back

krmurr87 wrote:gemma also seemed like a glenn creation so that could be another reason for her not coming back

I doubt it. She was a character in LG15 before OpAPHID became official. And her actor is a friend of Jessica Rose.

Lurker wrote:

krmurr87 wrote:gemma also seemed like a glenn creation so that could be another reason for her not coming back

I doubt it. She was a character in LG15 before OpAPHID became official. And her actor is a friend of Jessica Rose.

Yeah, the Creators and Glenn just embedded an already existing character into the OpAphid storyline through Tachyon showing she was working for OpAphid against BDJ.

I'd take Gemma over Jules any day. I hated her when she was around. After all this time I'm starting to miss her.

But I think Jackie was leaving and that is why they killed Gemma off.