Posted: Thu Mar 22, 2007 6:15 pm
I was thinking about this too. He chose a chemistry book and the letters were not a coincidence. Maybe he was trying to make the puzzle more difficult? He did say he was testing us.
Forum to post messages about Bree and Danielbeast
https://lg15.cassieiswatching.com/forum/
https://lg15.cassieiswatching.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7487
Great analysis Deagol! Thanks for posting this. And I must be learning something because I'm actually starting to understand what you're sayingdeagol wrote:Actually, he couldn't have avoided I, K, O, Y, given that he used octal ascii codes to make DNA, to make aminoacids.ignatzmouse wrote:So in retrospect this puzzle had a simple solution, I think the thing that bogged us down was the sidetrack into chemistry. I was sooo sure that IKYOIYK was Iodine_Potassium_etc and that ITIYETI was a good half-way solution.
Turns out that Walter just grabbed any old reference card with "8" on it, and the fact that I,K,O,Y are elements is pure coincidence (about a 1-in-12 coincidence). If Walter had grabbed pretty much any other card, I bet we'd have had this solution days ago.
Anyhow, we have the answer now, hooray! Hooray for Jane!
Since t=20 can't be used as a base in the DNA sequence, and a=1 is required as a starting base in every triplet in order to form a valid 3-digit octal ascii code, these are the 9 remaining combinations available:
So, turns out the only letters available for his coding system were I, K, O, Y, and y, and their respective aminoacids, K N K T R. If he didn't want to use that lowercase y that leaves only three aminoacids: lysine, asparagine, and threonine. The available letters from those are: aeghilnoprsty.Code: Select all
aaa aca aga = 111 131 171 = I Y y aac acc agc = 113 133 173 = K [ { aag acg agg = 117 137 177 = O _ DEL
Limiting the shifts to +/- 8 or 16, and even excluding any wrapping (-):Which shows how Walter did have every letter to chose from for his message, even after all those constraints, so he didn't really need that +24 shift, nor wrapping around z or a!Code: Select all
+0:aeghilnoprsty +8:imopqtvwxz--- +16:quwxy-------- -8:----adfghjklq -16:---------bcdi
Yup. It's not anything of Walter's doing that these 4 letters all happen to form element names, it's just an unfortunate coincidence that lead us down a garden path. Or, as jane said, he could be toying with us, bwah hah hah hah hah.deagol wrote: Actually, he couldn't have avoided I, K, O, Y, given that he used octal ascii codes to make DNA, to make aminoacids.
Ah, but that would have messed up his pretty pattern of ascending shifts with alternating +/-. With those additional restrictions, it's pretty amazing he managed to encrypt anything at all!deagol wrote: Which shows how Walter did have every letter to chose from for his message, even after all those constraints, so he didn't really need that +24 shift, nor wrapping around z or a!
Herring Are Forever.deagol wrote:Red herrings are the puzzle maker's best friends.
Haha way to sum up what I said in a more clever and shorter way. Deagol is still king.deagol wrote:Red herrings are the puzzle maker's best friends.
TOSG - Ready with your strategy! We may need to move into action!LuminousEmail wrote: What do you mean we've been destroying the cure - doing your dirty work for you?!
I'm not here to do anyone's "Dirty Work". I thought we were doing a good deed for an old man in need.
Adjust your bifocals you old fart. You're going to have to provide more information than that if you want our help!
We're gonna have a pissed off old man with the means to destroy civilization as we know it on our hands. Oh boy...Luminous wrote:I'm a little PO'd with Walter, so I just sent him a message. We'll see what he has to say about this:
TOSG - Ready with your strategy! We may need to move into action!LuminousEmail wrote: What do you mean we've been destroying the cure - doing your dirty work for you?!
I'm not here to do anyone's "Dirty Work". I thought we were doing a good deed for an old man in need.
Adjust your bifocals you old fart. You're going to have to provide more information than that if you want our help!
You are one smart Kitten! Take that Walter!ShardinsKitten wrote:see what we do is, keep the new viles he sends us and not open them right... and then we take the old ones we have re lable them and pretend they are the new ones. YEA! lol