Page 2 of 4
Posted: Mon Dec 04, 2006 9:14 pm
by Annabelle
I'm starting to wonder.. I mean I know it was supposed to look dramatic and sad and we were supposed to have sympathy when the video showed Bree on the park bench talking to her animals..
But I just
burst out laughing.. and I don't think I've ever really laughed watching the videos before.. like it was magic.. brilliant.
Can you imagine being in the park and seeing this girl who looks at least twenty just sitting there on her own talking to stuffed animals? Dear goodness... Oh, it's too much for me, it's just
too perfect..
Bree is definitely a few something short of something, I just don't know what.. I mean, used to be able to empathize with her, I think we all were.. I mean everyone, no matter who you were, could empathize with her in *some* way or another...
.. and now she's just the retarded girl you pass by in the mall food court and avoid making eye contact with.. >.<
Posted: Tue Dec 05, 2006 2:39 am
by Phoenician
I burst out laughing too . . . but realy because of Daniel's commetary -- he reminds me of when I criticize my sister always having her cell phone in her hands.
I doubt Bree is mental . . . but I do think that she is avoiding the issue with her stuffed animals.
Posted: Tue Dec 05, 2006 3:12 am
by Sami
Jeez, I seriously don't think she is metally challenged.
She may have issues..
Re: Is Bree Mentally Challenged?
Posted: Wed Dec 06, 2006 1:09 am
by Claramata
Jengels2002 wrote:I do not think this girl is playing with a full deck of cards. I mean, what kind of moron sits in a park talking to a stuffed animal?
What do you think?
Gee, don't you think you'd be a little bit 'off' too if you were going through some really insane stuff and living on the streets. The character of Bree isn't mentally challenged, just weird. And why is she weird? Because sometimes being silly is the only way to get your mind off pain. It's not an unrealistic response to problems, believe me. I actually like the fact that that's how Bree's coping with stuff, it shows a way of dealing with problems that you don't often see in fictional stories but that I've seen pretty dang often in my actual life.
Re: Is Bree Mentally Challenged?
Posted: Wed Dec 06, 2006 3:34 am
by melpomene
No, I don't think she's actually mentally challenged or has a psychological disorder. She doesn't really show signs of either.
She acts like someone who grew up very sheltered with few friends. She pretends her stuffed animals can talk because of her loneliness and now, she also uses them to escape reality and to cope. It's essentially a coping mechanism used to avoid how she really feels and to avoid dealing with things happening to her. She seems to have a firm grasp of reality but is very naive and a bit immature (at times).
I will admit I haven't seen all the videos but I've seen enough to know that she doesn't actually have a mental or emotional disorder.
Posted: Wed Dec 06, 2006 9:43 am
by absolution
Annabelle wrote:
.. and now she's just the retarded girl you pass by in the mall food court and avoid making eye contact with.. >.<
I just nearly peed my pants a little laughing at that. Oooh I'm going to hell.
Posted: Wed Dec 06, 2006 5:01 pm
by Sami
maybe the meds her father gave her where some sort of antipsycotic or somtn... No she don't get them and she's going to start talking to trees and eating her own fingers
Posted: Wed Dec 06, 2006 6:48 pm
by MrsCop
Sami wrote:she's going to start talking to trees and eating her own fingers
lmfao! I got an interesting visual from that
Re: Is Bree Mentally Challenged?
Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2006 2:47 pm
by Luv2Skydive
CoeMia wrote:Jengels2002 wrote:I do not think this girl is playing with a full deck of cards. I mean, what kind of moron sits in a park talking to a stuffed animal?
What do you think?
The same kind that goes on a date with that stuffed animal.
So does that mean Bree is engaging in beastiality.....or BREESTIALITY!
Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2006 2:50 pm
by Luv2Skydive
Phoenician wrote:I burst out laughing too . . . but realy because of Daniel's commetary -- he reminds me of when I criticize my sister always having her cell phone in her hands.
I doubt Bree is mental . . . but I do think that she is avoiding the issue with her stuffed animals.
I agree......do you think she watches the vids after he posts them? Cuz I don't think she'd be happy at what he says behind her back!
He needs to start playing jokes.....they would be lost on her and that would be so funny!
Come on Daniel, make Bree say "I AM WE TALL DID"!
Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2006 2:53 pm
by Luv2Skydive
MrsCop wrote:Sami wrote:she's going to start talking to trees and eating her own fingers
I SO just laughed out loud! I really did.....I'm not kidding.
I think she's an Idiot Savant. "Yeah, definitely not my underwear....."
Her gifts are talking to stuffed animals and waxing the perfect brow.
Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2006 2:57 pm
by wintermute
LesterG wrote:cassie-stylez
So, you're saying that CiW was the alternate personality of P-Monkey, not Bree?
'mute
Re: Is Bree Mentally Challenged?
Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2006 3:00 pm
by wintermute
childofmetis wrote:I thought she might be, actually. Maybe she has some form of autism?
Most geeks do show some signs of autism.
'mute
Re: Is Bree Mentally Challenged?
Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2006 3:31 pm
by Sami
wintermute wrote:childofmetis wrote:I thought she might be, actually. Maybe she has some form of autism?
Most geeks do show some signs of autism.
'mute
agreed
People whom suffer from Asperger, a mild form of autism, usually have one big interest. They always wan't to talk about it. They read alot about that one subject.
A geek... a nerd can be a person who is really engaed to one interest
but this is so far off... Why are we talking about autism? Not like the plot's going like 'Bree went to a doctor and got diagnosed with Asperger Syndrome and Daniel ate a banana'
Re: Is Bree Mentally Challenged?
Posted: Thu Dec 07, 2006 3:39 pm
by wintermute
Sami wrote:but this is so far off... Why are we talking about autism? Not like the plot's going like 'Bree went to a doctor and got diagnosed with Asperger Syndrome and Daniel ate a banana'
No clue... I was just agreeing that it was a possibility.
'mute