Page 8 of 9
Posted: Tue Apr 17, 2007 5:56 pm
by islandlove
Jules must know about them, the videos were replies to bree's
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 1:56 am
by Sappho
Languorous Lass wrote:
I get a total Baby Dyke vibe from her. She says her priorities are Sam, soccer, and (I think) school, with god and country and all that stuff way below. Sounds exactly like me when I was about 13 (except for the soccer part) -- totally crushed out on another girl. Except that I knew perfectly well what I was feeling and was terrified by it. This Taylor sounds like she may not know what she's feeling just yet.
IOW, Taylor is somebody whom I (or my inner adolescent) can identify with, a whole lot more than I ever could with Bree.
EDITED TO ADD: And maybe that's why some of you straight girls are so turned off by Taylor -- because you're subconsciously picking up a dyke vibe from her too. I wonder what Misty thinks of her.
I thought the same thing, LL. She looked like someone I would have had a crush on at 13. I felt sorry for her being stuck in that awful fuschia/magenta room and wearing makeup. Totally unnatural on her! If Taylor's the new girl, they have to get her out of that room before I get sick looking at it and drop out.
Please, someone, kidnap this girl!
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 2:27 am
by Aithne
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 8:03 am
by silvermoon
islandlove wrote:Jules must know about them, the videos were replies to bree's
Taylor's video was in reply to Bree, but not Jules'. I messaged back and forth with Jules, and she's never watched any lonelygirl videos. Or course I quickly suggested that she do so! I'm sure many other people have contacted her by now with a lot of info and suggestions, as well.
tenshiakui wrote:voyboy wrote:I haven't seen this mentioned anywhere, so if I am repeating what has already been said, sorry in advance.
Taylor cant be the new girl. She has been following the LG15 vids and story. She knows all about the Order and the Ceremony etc...
Very valid point!
Unless, as someone else mentioned, she's not the "new girl" but her friend Sam is. But either way. Very valid point!

Or perhaps the newest "find" is someone that the Order just found. Maybe she wasn't raised as a member of the Hymn of One. Her parents might have escaped the Order or something.
The fact that she already knows the videos would make it a little stupid at this point if she were the new girl, though, that's completely true. How much coincidance can one series have? We already have the strange connection between random viewer Jonas and the Order.
Unless we assume that the entire world (except viewers that haven't gone over to the Order side, lol) is somehow connected to the Order, lol!
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 9:28 am
by llama_burger
sadly, i think she has to be canon... everything's there, down to the room furnished out of ikea (or similar). seriously, what soccer-playing 14 year old has a room that tidy? and wears makeup? she's definitely scripted, and it's too big a coincidence if she's not canon.
she's more likely than jules i thought, just cuz the look is so much more the same, plus jules' makeup was overdone, which bree's never was. it's only nikki B and bree's vid that's making me consider jules... if she's not, poor girl, getting all this attention and criticism. but then, i thought she was pretty scripted too... video challenge methinks.
that pony girl i thought was video challenge thingy too.
so my conclusion? we've got to put up with this soccerstar girl. just wish she wasn't so phony.
anyway it's half past 2 in the morning, my broadband's been down all day so i just got the last 2 videos and all this new girl stuff and i gotta stop rambling!
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 9:31 am
by silvermoon
Didn't Jules' video come out before the video challenge was issued?
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 9:49 am
by Libra
silvermoon wrote:Didn't Jules' video come out before the video challenge was issued?
Yes. Her first videos were posted before last weekend.
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 9:53 am
by Languorous Lass
The video challenge was not creator-generated. It was a fan idea that sprang from the theories being tossed about on the board about why so many potential "New Girls" -- including Jules -- were suddenly springing up.
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 9:55 am
by Kasdeja
Just commenting on the room tidyness....Uh...my room was ALWAYS tidy as a teenager?
O.k...backing away now.
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:33 am
by nowherepixie
Kasdeja wrote:Just commenting on the room tidyness....Uh...my room was ALWAYS tidy as a teenager?
O.k...backing away now.
Well you were very good then
Mine was awful...
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:35 am
by chershaytoute
Uhhhh... My room was absolutely always that tidy, Kas. But my mother was a bit...odd. Among other things, I was required to fold dirty clothes to put them into the hamper.
Maybe I'm an Order baby? Just a really, really WAY-past Ceremony one?
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:40 am
by nowherepixie
chershaytoute wrote:Uhhhh... My room was absolutely always that tidy, Kas. But my mother was a bit...odd. Among other things, I was required to fold dirty clothes to put them into the hamper.
Maybe I'm an Order baby? Just a really, really WAY-past Ceremony one?
Maybe you are!
But that video with Daniel's room in seems too tidy too. I've never seen a teenage boy's room that tidy! But of course that might just be my mates!
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:43 am
by Languorous Lass
Just to get on my gender soapbox for a minute . . .
When I was a teenage girl, my room was a disaster area. (Still is, come to think of it.)
My brother is 18 months younger, and his room was always spotless. Now that we're both adults, his apartment is spotless. (And yes, for those of you who believe stereotypes about sexual orientation, he is straight.)
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:46 am
by nowherepixie
Languorous Lass wrote:Just to get on my gender soapbox for a minute . . .
When I was a teenage girl, my room was a disaster area. (Still is, come to think of it.)
My brother is 18 months younger, and his room was always spotless. Now that we're both adults, his apartment is spotless. (And yes, for those of you who believe stereotypes about sexual orientation, he is straight.)
Haha well yep. I was just speaking from experience there. And to be honest my mates are all in their 20s now and their house is
still a tip.
I found a pizza under their sofa the other day...
Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:50 am
by Languorous Lass
nowherepixie wrote:I found a pizza under their sofa the other day...
How old was it? And did they know it was there?
Reminds me of a classic scene from the old "The Odd Couple" U.S. TV show, about two guys who shared an apartment. One was a slob and the other was obsessively neat.
The slob, Oscar, had some friends over to play poker. I think he invited them to go rummage in the fridge for food.
One of the pals found a sandwich and pulled up the top slice of bread. "What's in this sandwich? It's green."
Oscar came over and inspected the sandwich contents. "Well, it's either very new cheese, or very old meat."