Decoys?

sidewalkflight · Post by **sidewalkflight** » Tue Apr 17, 2007 7:46 pm

It seems odd to me that there are 2 characters out there (Jules and Socerstar) introduced at the same time, both with VERY Creator-esque production quality. Maybe it's possible there is no new girl... and this is just to throw Bree off. If more videos in the same style show up this may be evidence.

I'm sure this theory has been brought up before. Discuss it here, I suppose.

ApotheosisAZ · Post by **ApotheosisAZ** » Tue Apr 17, 2007 9:16 pm

Certainly a possibility, but if this is a clever ruse by The Order to fool Bree, then it is a Plot Discussion topic. I'll just move this there now.

janesalteredstates · Post by **janesalteredstates** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 12:00 am

I like that! But I doubt it.

I think they have been pretty clear that the Bree story will be ... changing? Not ending. Ending is the wrong word... Oh what am I trying to say? Someone help me out.

mincartaugh · Post by **mincartaugh** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 1:37 am

morphing?
bifurcating?
metamorphosing?
growing up?
branching off?
dichotomizing?
divaricating?
forking?
hemisecting?
separating?
splitting?
franchising?
expanding?
seeking new horizons?
bloating?
seeking the money?
spreading?
hallucinating?

theratdiva · Post by **theratdiva** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 1:44 am

Perhaps Bree inadvertantly gave herself a clue in her "New Girl" video. Bree herself states that she would think that the Order would keep their new girl from posting online and bringing attention to herself. I think she's right.

If there really were a new girl, I think that the Order would tell her parents to remove all video cameras since that ruined their attempt to convince Bree.

I think that these "new girls" are meant to confuse and distract Bree and that the Order wants them to be seen so that Bree will believe that they are in danger.

Languorous Lass · Post by **Languorous Lass** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 9:21 am

theratdiva wrote:Perhaps Bree inadvertantly gave herself a clue in her "New Girl" video. Bree herself states that she would think that the Order would keep their new girl from posting online and bringing attention to herself. I think she's right.

If there really were a new girl, I think that the Order would tell her parents to remove all video cameras since that ruined their attempt to convince Bree.

Now this is a very interesting theory. I like it.

nowherepixie · Post by **nowherepixie** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:08 am

Languorous Lass wrote:
theratdiva wrote:Perhaps Bree inadvertantly gave herself a clue in her "New Girl" video. Bree herself states that she would think that the Order would keep their new girl from posting online and bringing attention to herself. I think she's right.

If there really were a new girl, I think that the Order would tell her parents to remove all video cameras since that ruined their attempt to convince Bree.
Now this is a very interesting theory. I like it.

Me too. If the Order did have another ceremony girl, not putting a cap on all the stuff that turned Bree against it would be amateurish and foolish.

impulse · Post by **impulse** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:19 am

mincartaugh wrote:morphing?
bifurcating?
metamorphosing?
growing up?
branching off?
dichotomizing?
divaricating?
forking?
hemisecting?
separating?
splitting?
franchising?
expanding?
seeking new horizons?
bloating?
seeking the money?
spreading?
hallucinating?

nowherepixie · Post by **nowherepixie** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 10:19 am

impulse wrote:
mincartaugh wrote:morphing?
bifurcating?
metamorphosing?
growing up?
branching off?
dichotomizing?
divaricating?
forking?
hemisecting?
separating?
splitting?
franchising?
expanding?
seeking new horizons?
bloating?
seeking the money?
spreading?
hallucinating?

Thesaurus anyone?

watermelonhead · Post by **watermelonhead** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 1:13 pm

I like the 'decoy' theory.

The Order wants Bree to think there is a new girl so:

a) Bree lets her guard down, thinking that she's 'off-the-hook' since she has an alleged replacement. When she LEAST expects it she gets potato sack over the head and is captured!

b) They are using the decoy as 'bait'. Bree mentioned in a recent video that she does not want other girls to go experience the same potential fate. Bree may try to be a hero and intercept/save the decoy.... falling right into the hands of The Order

Lurker · Post by **Lurker** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 2:28 pm

watermelonhead wrote:I like the 'decoy' theory.

The Order wants Bree to think there is a new girl so:

a) Bree lets her guard down, thinking that she's 'off-the-hook' since she has an alleged replacement. When she LEAST expects it she gets potato sack over the head and is captured!

b) They are using the decoy as 'bait'. Bree mentioned in a recent video that she does not want other girls to go experience the same potential fate. Bree may try to be a hero and intercept/save the decoy.... falling right into the hands of The Order

Doesn't make sense. They had Bree right in front of them when Alex said that. They could have probably taken her then if they'd wanted to. While they may not have anticipated Jonas' gun, if they really wanted to grab her and not have any trouble, they could have gotten her that day if they were intent on it (she was sleeping in Alex's house after all).

nowherepixie · Post by **nowherepixie** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 3:06 pm

Lurker wrote:
Doesn't make sense. They had Bree right in front of them when Alex said that. They could have probably taken her then if they'd wanted to. While they may not have anticipated Jonas' gun, if they really wanted to grab her and not have any trouble, they could have gotten her that day if they were intent on it (she was sleeping in Alex's house after all).

They can't grab her I dont think. From all the evidence so far she has to do it of her own free will.

Lurker · Post by **Lurker** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 3:11 pm

nowherepixie wrote:
Lurker wrote:
Doesn't make sense. They had Bree right in front of them when Alex said that. They could have probably taken her then if they'd wanted to. While they may not have anticipated Jonas' gun, if they really wanted to grab her and not have any trouble, they could have gotten her that day if they were intent on it (she was sleeping in Alex's house after all).
They can't grab her I dont think. From all the evidence so far she has to do it of her own free will.

That too. I just don't buy the idea that they're trying to get her to put down her guard. They could have taken her - or killed her - so many times by now (and I mean that in terms of from the time they decided they were going to get someone else) if that's what they wanted.

sidewalkflight · Post by **sidewalkflight** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 4:42 pm

Kind of a longshot, but maybe if Bree fears for the new girl she'll do it herself so they don't have to.

theratdiva · Post by **theratdiva** » Wed Apr 18, 2007 4:53 pm

That's exactly it, Sidewalk!

They need Bree to do it of her own free will... I completely believe that Bree is the sort who would agree to do the ceremony to spare another person. They tried to use Daniel to manipulate her, but that didn't work: Tachyon intervened. I have a feeling that the Order is trying this trick once more, using a "new girl" this time to manipulate Bree. I think, as well, that there are multiple candidates for the "new girl" in order to confuse Bree and keep her attention divided amongst the girls.